US · beach
Key West, FL with Points
United States
- Home
- Destinations
- Key West, FL
Hemingway's island, sunsets at Mallory Square, Caribbean vibes without a passport
Dec-Apr ideal (72-82°F). Summer hot/humid with frequent storms. Hurricane risk Jun-Nov, esp. Sept.
When to visit
Award flights from the US
Economy
American AAdvantage
+ $20 taxes
AA economy JFK-EYW via MIA (regional jet last leg)
Chase Ultimate Rewards
via Southwest Rapid Rewards
+ $30 taxes
Chase UR → Southwest to MIA/FLL, then drive 4h (Overseas Hwy)
Business / First
American AAdvantage
+ $20 taxes
AA business JFK-MIA, then connect on regional
Cash equivalent: economy ~$350 · business ~$1,200 roundtrip from NYC
Award hotels
Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
Hyatt
Cat 6 — Old Town location, walk to Duval Street.
Casa Marina, A Waldorf Astoria Resort
Hilton Honors
Dynamic 70-120K. Historic 1920s beachfront.
The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Hilton Honors
Dynamic — sister to Casa Marina, more contemporary.
Points vs cash: the trip math
What each award is worth in cents per point, from the typical cash price of the same flight or night.
A 5-night trip for one — the cheapest economy award plus the cheapest hotel award — takes about 170,000 points in place of about $2,850 in cash, roughly 1.7¢ per point. You still pay about $1,080 out of pocket for award taxes, food, activities and local transport.
| Option | Points | Cash price | ¢ per point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Economy round trip · American AAdvantage | 30,000 | $350 | 1.1 |
| Economy round trip · Chase Ultimate Rewards | 20,000 | $350 | 1.6 |
| Business / First round trip · American AAdvantage | 55,000 | $1,200 | 2.1 |
| Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa · per night | 30,000 | $500 | 1.7 |
| Casa Marina, A Waldorf Astoria Resort · per night | 90,000 | $750 | 0.8 |
| The Reach Key West, Curio Collection · per night | 75,000 | $600 | 0.8 |
Cash prices are typical round-trip fares from the New York area and typical nightly rates; your dates will differ. Out-of-pocket figures are estimates.
What to see & do
Mallory Square Sunset Celebration
Nightly street performers + sunset over the Gulf — Key West tradition since the 1960s.
Hemingway Home
Author's 1851 home with 60 six-toed cats. Tours daily.
Southernmost Point Buoy
Iconic colorful concrete buoy, 90 miles from Cuba. Photo op (with queue).
Duval Street
24-hour party street with bars, drag shows, live music.
Dry Tortugas National Park
70 miles west by ferry/seaplane — Fort Jefferson + pristine snorkeling.
Cuban Coffee Queen
Local cafecito + cubano sandwich shop. Bustling local favorite.
Monthly weather
Best cards for this trip
Open Hilton Aspire (150K Hilton bonus) + Sapphire Preferred. Aspire covers Casa Marina Resort (Waldorf Astoria) 2 weekend nights free + bonus = 5+ nights.
More US destinations on points
Plan your Key West, FL trip
Get a full flight + hotel + card strategy personalized to you